Should football cleats be tight?
In conclusion, football cleats should not be too tight to cause blisters but not too loose to where the cleats fall off or could cause an ankle injury.
Cleated Shoe Fitting Guide. First and foremost, cleats should fit comfortably enough to allow your foot to flex and make swift movements. Cleats that are too tight will be uncomfortable and cleats that are too loose will pose an injury risk to your foot.
Your soccer cleat should fit as close to the end of your toes as possible without touching them, about a ¼ inch gap. Cleats that are too big can negatively influence your performance and can sometimes lead to injuries.
They should be tight but at the same time, you should be able to flex with your foot. Usually, brand new cleats tend to feel too tight, but once you break in cleats, that tightness goes away. If it persists, consider getting a bigger size.
A general rule of thumb is to have a ¼ - ½ inch gap between your toes and the top of the boots. In this case, if you have a thumb space between your toes and the top of the boots, they're too big.
The most important thing to note about leather football boots is that they will stretch over time. If your leather boots feel snug when you first try them on, keep in mind they will become more roomy as you wear them out.
A proper fit is important for both comfort and stability. A tight fit can cause discomfort and restrict movement, while a loose fit can cause blisters and slipping.
A well fit cycling shoe should be snug in the heel with even pressure on the instep. You should not be pressed against the end. You should have a little toe room at the end of a well fit cycling shoe and the shoe should hold your forefoot stable without pinching or restricting.
Shoes that are too big can cause a variety of problems, from blisters and foot pain to tripping and falling. On the other hand, shoes that are too small can be equally uncomfortable and can even lead to long-term foot problems.
First, make sure your cleats fit correctly. The wrong size could lead to blisters, ingrown toenails, and other lower limb injuries. Any pair should be fairly comfortable when you first try it on. Your feet should fit snugly without feeling cramped.
Should I be able to wiggle my toes in cleats?
Your toes need wiggle room so that you don't get blisters, calluses or damaged toenails. You should be able to wiggle your toes comfortably in the toe box and if you aren't sure how much room is enough, use the “rule of thumb” when purchasing new shoes.
A general rule of thumb is to have about a finger's width of space between the end of your toes and the front of the cleat. This will help to prevent your toes from rubbing against the front of the cleat and reduce the risk of blisters.

Generally speaking, there should be about one finger's width of space between your longest toe and the end of the shoe. Another way to check this is to slip a finger between the heel of your foot and the heel of your shoe. There should be just enough space for your finger to fit nice and snugly.
Too far forward will overload the lower leg muscles, similar to standing on your toes for a long period, whilst too far back will strain the upper leg muscles. Both scenarios will fatigue the localized areas, often resulting in pain and cramping, and significantly reduce the power transferred during the pedal stroke.
New football boots can mean sore feet, that is until the new football boots and your feet get used to each other. Even if you are dusting off last year's equipment, your feet and football boots may need to readjust to each other again, so there will be another breaking in period.
Most cleats are notorious for their extremely narrow fit, tight toe-box, and inflexible sole. The reasons behind the narrow toe-box is in order to assist in cutting (changing direction on a field); the shoe acts as a snug extension of your foot, which in turn ensures that your toes don't slip, or move around.
OFF FIELD TIPS – use your cleats properly
Finally, use your cleats like cleats. Work them hard, but please do not walk on concrete in your cleats. This will damage the studs and will make them less effective.
The cleats are designed to give athletes a better ability to “grip” the ground and control their balance and “footing” on the surface. Unfortunately, the decrease in surface area that is in contact with the ground hinders the foot's chances of being totally stable.
There's nothing more exciting than getting a new pair of cleats, and if you're like me, you probably want to take them straight to the field. However, like all shoes, you'll need to break your soccer cleats in before they're comfortable enough to wear.
In most cases, a tighter fit is recommended for soccer cleats, so your standard shoe size may not be the size you end up in with a soccer shoe. Your soccer cleat should fit as close to the end of your foot as possible, without touching your toes. A 1/4 to 1/2 inch gap is ideal.
Where should cleats sit?
As a basic rule of thumb, you're looking to position the shoe cleat so that it's centre point is just inboard of the ball of your big toe. Laterally, the front (tip) of the cleat should follow the line of your middle toe. These are good starting points for basic cleat positioning on a new shoe.
The cleat should be positioned as far back as possible on the shoe to allow the ideal rider-specific compromise between foot stability, calf muscle energy input and sprinting ability.
Other painful effects of wearing shoes that are too big include: Corns and calluses: caused by excessive pressure on the toes. Metatarsalgia: caused by too much pressure on the balls of your feet. Disrupted natural stride: resulting in Achilles tendonitis, arch pain, and pain in the calf muscles.
Method #3: Shrink them with a blowdryer
Again, start by wetting your shoes by soaking them in a bucket of water for 30 minutes. Then, use a hair dryer to dry them! The heat from the blowdryer will help shrink your shoes.
During work or when catching up on Netflix at home, pull on a comfortable pair of socks, and lace up in your new boots. Leave them on for at least 30 minutes for the boot to break in by moulding around feet, although for best effects, do try to walk around in them every few minutes to have the upper ease up.
When the fronts are too tight—as soccer and football cleats can be—they pinch the sides of your toes, making the nail grow into the skin. The results are swelling, redness, pain, and possibly infection. So what do you do to protect yourself? Buy shoes that fit properly, and lace them correctly.
The authors concluded that Edge cleat design for football shoes may significantly contribute to the risk of serious knee injury. They further recommended that the non-Edge cleat be used to prevent major knee injury.
As a rule of thumb (or toe), you should have about 3/8″ to 1/2″ of room from the tip of your longest toe to the end of the shoe. Your big toe is not automatically your longest toe.
As long as you can wiggle your toes a little, you should have enough room to ensure full circulation. Of course, everyone's feet are different, and if your cleats are super painful to wear (especially after they're broken in), you need to select a different size.
Don't use boiling water or very hot water as this can breakdown the glue which the boots have been made with and ruin your new kicks as well as burning your feet. The hot water helps to make the shoes flexible, and once they cool, they will set and form to the shape of your foot, making them comfortable.
How much height do cleats add?
New cleats can add 1-2cm of height onto the bottom of your foot, which will change your riding position if you don't adjust your saddle height. So remember to tweak your riding position as a whole if and when you make any adjustments to your cleats.
Soft ground (SG) football boots are the ideal partner for soft, wet and muddy grass pitches. In the modern era, you're more likely to see traditional soft ground metal studs mixed with firm ground plastic mould formations. Nike's Anti-Clog tech is a perfect example of this style.
Hot Water Trick (break in cleats naturally) If you are trying to break in your cleats quickly, a trick that some professional players use is to soak their cleats in hot/warm water with their feet inside. This softens the material quickly and reforms around their foot shape.
If the water is very hot, it can melt the adhesives and other materials used on the football boot. A simple way to achieve this is to put on some football socks and your new boots with the laces tied up. Then sit in the bath for 15-20 minutes and this will help the boots to mould to your unique foot shape.
Generally speaking, a football boot will fit true to regular shoe size. That said, some players (especially elite-level athletes) prefer their boots to fit much more snug than, say, a pair of running shoes. This is because elite-level athletes tend to prefer a more sensitive touch on the ball.
Any pair should be fairly comfortable when you first try it on. Your feet should fit snugly without feeling cramped. The toe box should be long enough, too—you need roughly half an inch of space between your toe tips and the front of the shoe.
Plantar Fasciitis: With the pressure of playing a game of football going through the soles of your feet, it's common that the plantar fascia – the strip that runs from your heel to your toes on the sole of your foot – can become inflamed or torn. This pain can be felt in the heel and/or arch of the foot.
Apply Heat
A blow dryer can be used to heat and soften leather boots. We recommend heating it at least 4-6 inches away for about one minute. After heating, you can wear your leather shoes with thick socks to stretch them out.
High-cut cleats offer the most support for the ankle as they lace all the way above the ankle. While these cleats can boost support, they can also affect the mobility of athletes wearing them. High-cut cleats can be a good option for linemen.
If you're someone who prefers a little bit of extra space then go a half-size up from your true to size fit. Similarly, stick true to size if you like having the most feeling of the ball when it's at your feet. Do not go down a half-size.
Is it OK to wear boots half a size too big?
Is it OK to wear boots a size too big? It's OK to size up if you secure your foot in place with insoles or heel shields. It's not OK if your feet are sliding around in the boot, your heels are slipping, and the flex points are misaligned. This causes blisters, inflammation, and plantar fasciitis.
If your shoes are only too big by a half-size or one full size, you can try some of these tactics to make them fit better: Insert a full-size shoe insole. Add heel strips or liners. Insert toe cushions.
References
- https://www.cyclingnews.com/features/cycling-with-cleats-everything-you-need-to-know/
- https://www.mfcofficialdirect.co.uk/blog/6-ways-to-make-your-new-football-boots-fit/
- https://bakershoe.com/blogs/news/how-to-stretch-and-soften-leather-boots
- https://www.soccerplususa.com/info/shoe-fitting
- https://www.soccer.com/guide/10-tips-to-get-the-most-out-of-your-cleats
- https://www.gfclinic.com/if-the-shoe-fits/
- https://patelpodiatry.com/blog/breaking-in-footbal-cleats/
- https://www.medicinenet.com/football_knee_ligament_injury/views.htm
- https://ballathlete.com/how-tight-should-soccer-cleats-be/
- https://www.dickssportinggoods.com/protips/sports-and-activities/football/gridiron-guide-how-to-buy-the-right-football-cleats
- https://bootspy.com/boots-too-big/
- https://www.feetbypody.com/blog/podiatry-in-football/
- http://www.anbfutbol.com/Breaking%20in%20New%20Futbol%20Boots.pdf
- https://tokay-ultimate.com/welcome-how-to-maintain-your-cleats/
- https://fitwerx.com/cycling-shoe-fit-how-should-a-well-fit-shoe-feel-and-other-considerations/
- https://www.footy-boots.com/breaking-in-your-new-football-boots/
- https://boothype.com/2021/12/02/how-to-break-in-your-new-football-boots/
- https://neillsbikefit.com.au/?page_id=348
- https://www.kitqueen.com/how-to-shrink-football-boots/
- https://www.soccer.com/guide/how-to-choose-the-right-soccer-cleat-size
- https://www.rogansshoes.com/cleated-shoe-fitting-guide
- https://yoursoccerhome.com/8-steps-to-break-in-soccer-cleats-fast/
- https://www.soccerpro.com/theinstep/how-much-space-should-you-have-in-football-boots/
- https://upper90football.com/how-tight-should-football-boots-be/
- https://road.cc/content/feature/how-get-your-shoe-cleats-set-right-170333
- https://www.soccerpro.com/theinstep/how-much-toe-room-should-your-soccer-cleats-have/
- https://whentheshoefits.com/pages/proper-fit
- https://www.myactivesg.com/sports/football/how-to-play/football-equipment/which-football-boots-to-wear
- https://www.footankleinstitute.com/blog/can-i-wear-oversized-shoes/
- https://www.clarks.co.uk/editorial/how-should-shoes-fit
- https://www.thebarefootshoereview.com/post/cleat-options-for-barefoot-enthusiasts-by-sean-haber
- https://www.nike.com/il/a/how-should-football-boots-fit
- https://www.fourfourtwo.com/features/what-size-football-boots-should-i-get
- https://ace-pt.org/ace-physical-therapy-and-sports-medicine-institute-cleated-shoes-and-foot-pain/
- https://www.footy.com/blog/boots/boot-surface-type-guide
- https://www.quora.com/Should-cleats-be-tight-or-loose
- https://stridewise.com/boots-too-big/
- https://www.ankle-footspecialist.com/blog/protect-your-toenails-from-your-sports-shoes
- https://cyclingmagazine.ca/sections/training-guide/technique/how-to-adjust-your-cleats/